During Avengers Infinity War, Iron Man, Doctor Strange, Spider-Man and the Guardians of the Galaxy managed to tie down Thanos on Titan. But just before they removed the Infinity Gauntlet from his grasp, Star-Lord hit him for killing Gamora, causing the Mad Titan to wake up and break free. The rest, as Marvel fans know, is history as Thanos went on to kill half the universe.

Star-Lord was heavily blamed for the Avengers’ defeat by fans, but now a new fan theory argues that it was a good move by the Guardians of the Galaxy captain.

Reddit user HansDanz argues: “Doctor Strange saw all 14,000,605 outcomes of the battle and only foresaw one where the Avengers won.

“The fact that he didn’t stop Star-Lord from hitting Thanos already tells…